On the afternoon of Wednesday, Might 21, 2025, in a windowless, high-ceilinged courtroom in Brooklyn, Decide Eric Komitee learn the jury’s verdict.
On the cost of conspiracy to commit wire fraud: responsible.
On the cost of conspiracy to commit cash laundering: responsible.
On the cost of conspiracy to commit securities fraud: responsible.
Former SafeMoon CEO Braden John Karony had been convicted of a conspiracy to defraud buyers within the infamous token. Karony, tall and bearded, sat by the trial in a razor-sharp blue swimsuit, absorbing proof towards him with calm detachment.
He barely reacted to the decision.
Against this, former SafeMoon buyers all over the world celebrated wildly. For them, Karony’s conviction was vindication after an almost four-year wrestle to show they’d been ripped off.
Over the course of a 12-day trial, authorities prosecutors had satisfied a jury that Karony and his co-conspirator had lied about SafeMoon’s options and funds, whereas extracting as a lot as $200 million in what might be described as a “slow rug-pull.”
Learn extra: SafeMoon CEO branded ‘remorseless liar’ in explosive closing argument
Now Karony faces so long as 45 years in jail — although his sentence is more likely to be a lot much less. Certainly, former FTX head Sam Bankman-Fried solely obtained 25 years for a fraud practically 50 instances bigger.
That’s only one index of SafeMoon’s relative insignificance. Most crypto veterans regarded it as a little bit of a joke even at launch, and its dramatic collapse beneath scandalous fraud allegations was overshadowed by bigger and extra stunning frauds, like Three Arrows Capital, Celsius, and the aforementioned FTX.
Nonetheless, the SafeMoon saga, in all its low-rent absurdity, bitter infighting, grandiose delusion, and sheer incompetence, could also be a greater encapsulation of crypto’s maximum-fraud period than these slick, respectable-looking cons.
If Su Zhu and Alex Mashinsky flew too near the solar, Karony and his co-conspirators barely obtained off the bottom — however nonetheless managed to crash again down at full velocity.
Now, Karony is about to be what SafeMoon’s liquidity by no means actually was: locked up.
Right here’s the way it all went down.
Contained in the Japanese District
Each courthouse is a self-contained world, slightly island surprisingly insulated from the 21st century.
The Japanese District of New York courthouse sits on the sting of a picturesque park in a quiet pocket close to downtown Brooklyn, the place youngsters privileged past most individuals’s wildest desires play soccer on a flawless inexperienced.
Any member of the general public can watch a trial like Karony’s, however you first have to provide up your smartphone.
On the Southern District of New York in Manhattan, you hand it over in alternate for an historic stamped-metal chip, like a subway token. On the EDNY, they provide you a numbered block of wooden.
The telephone check-ins (and metallic detectors and bag-scans) are manned by US Marshals, however you received’t stumble upon Raylan Givens on the EDNY. Most Marshalls listed here are greying, jovial retirees from the NYPD or Federal legislation enforcement — pleasant within the laconic approach of people who find themselves used to respect by default.
Rumor has it that the former Feds and former cops keep a good-natured rivalry.
Decide Komitee’s courtroom is on the sixth ground of the expansive EDNY constructing, on the far finish of an echoing hallway. Down one facet hall are a half-dozen chrome telephone cubicles, now stripped of {hardware}.
One imagines journalists of an earlier period furiously submitting updates down the wire.
Now, the cubicles are a useful place to stash a cup of espresso — banned from the courtrooms themselves.
Komitee’s courtroom is, in a phrase, cavernous — as vast as a basketball court docket, with two-storey ceilings. The choose, appointed in 2018, looms above the fray on the far finish. He’s youthful for a Federal choose, resembling Ben Affleck solely with greater ears.
From the trial’s opening moments, Karony appeared at an obstacle. Partly as a result of he was being tried within the Japanese District within the first place: Federal prosecutors typically search jurisdiction to attempt monetary crimes in both the EDNY or SDNY, the place judges and attorneys have been placing away con-men like Bernie Madoff for a lot of many years.
This displays the fact that New York is the hub of American banking and finance: practically all transactions worldwide contact the bottom right here in a technique or one other. Jurisdiction galore.
It additionally signifies that everybody right here is exceptionally good at this monetary crime stuff — the prosecution most of all.
There’s one other facet impact that will additionally are inclined to benefit the prosecution: a jury pool of New Yorkers, breathers of Wall Avenue air, swimming in advanced monetary schemes, NFT bullshit spray-painted on the partitions of Williamsburg.
Karony’s jury, in a field on the left facet of the courtroom, sat at consideration for a lot of the trial, even by some actually interminable wrangling in regards to the trivialities of decentralized finance. Almost all took detailed notes.
One alternate’s unbelievable lineup of outfits taught day by day classes about menswear.
5 attorneys and aides sat on the prosecution’s desk, simply in entrance of the jury. Notably, the lead prosecutors have been all girls, together with Assistant US Lawyer Jessica Weigel and AUSA Dana Rehnquist, who would ship a bruising closing assertion.
Weigel, petite and understated, delivered the federal government’s opening.
“John Karony lied to investors so he could get rich,” she mentioned. “He wanted the public to buy [his] project, so he told them it was different… he told them it was safe. It was right there in the name.”
SafeMoon’s foremost pitch, Weigel recounted, had been a promise to “lock” a liquidity pool that assured customers may all the time promote. “That was a lie,” Weigel informed the jury.
SafeMoon did lock a few of the tokens that flowed into the pool from a “tax” on transactions, she added — “enough to calm investors’ nerves, to cover their tracks.”
Weigel informed the jury they’d hear about this intimately, and in particular person, from Thomas “Papa” Smith, the previous SafeMoon CTO. Smith had been charged alongside Karony however pleaded responsible, selecting to testify towards his former boss.
A 3rd conspirator had additionally been charged — Kyle Nagy, aka SafeMoonDev, had fled to Russia moderately than face trial.
The three wanted to cowl their tracks as a result of, the federal government would argue, “from the very beginning, [they] had been stealing from the pool.” Cash generated from SafeMoon charges had gone, to not help buyers’ tokens, however to fund extravagant purchases by the co-conspirators.
Within the basic vein of tasteless, impulsive nouveau-riche scammers, they splurged on Porsches, a number of Audi R8s, not less than one McLaren, a number of homes, and bag after bag of luxurious garments.
Karony’s mom was a fan of Louis Vuitton — and she or he was removed from alone.
Karony’s different clear handicap was the dimensions of his protection group — only one lawyer, Nicholas Smith, and a legislation clerk. Karony’s earlier authorized illustration, from the agency Petrillo, Klein & Boxer, had requested to be faraway from the case in February of 2024, after SafeMoon shut down and stopped paying Karony’s authorized charges.
Decide Komitee on the time directed Karony to hunt authorized help by the Felony Justice Act, which supplies public funding for defendants unable to pay for their very own attorneys.
Regardless of constrained sources, Karony clearly obtained fortunate with Nicholas Smith as his fill-in. A slight and boyish man with a understanding smirk and glasses, Smith got here to court docket with a full-sized chip on his shoulder, taking hammer and tongs to each potential seam within the prosecution’s case.
“The government has made a mistake,” he declared in his opening assertion. Their proof would “seem impressive and thorough,” however Smith guided the jury to “ask yourself two questions.”
First, “did John Karony agree with someone else to deceive someone? Or did he repeatedly disclose the information he’s accused of hiding?” Second, “did the [SafeMoon] team agree? Or did they constantly disagree? If it’s the second, you have to ask yourself … is that a conspiracy?”
These have been pillars of Smith’s surprisingly credible protection. Lots of the misleading claims about SafeMoon’s liquidity pool have been first made by Nagy, who named the undertaking and created a whitepaper and web site earlier than Karony joined.
Actually, inside days of becoming a member of SafeMoon, Karony directed adjustments to those paperwork that softened a few of Nagy’s lies. As a result of Karony was charged with conspiracy, these finer distinctions of duty may not have been exculpatory in authorized phrases — however they stood an opportunity of influencing the jury.
Whereas parts of SafeMoon’s messaging continued to assert that the pool was “locked,” Nicholas Smith additionally highlighted a number of situations the place Karony or “Papa” Smith appeared to acknowledge that the locking was incomplete.
Smith would emphasize these sometimes-indirect acknowledgments whereas emphasizing the function of liquidity withdrawals in professional enterprise actions, comparable to funding SafeMoon buying and selling on new exchanges.
Lastly, Nicholas Smith informed the jury that John Karony barely understood the phrases popping out of his personal mouth when he was allegedly defrauding SafeMoon buyers. When he joined SafeMoon, Smith mentioned, Karony knew “next to nothing about cryptocurrency or liquidity pools.”
Incompetence is never a terrific protection towards monetary fraud fees, however in Karony’s case, it had the good thing about being true.
Workers would later describe Karony, with outstanding consistency, as a genuinely good particular person whom they loved working with.
Nonetheless, he had little precise enterprise expertise, was additionally “easily manipulated,” and was “a narcissist.” In a single significantly egregious screwup, a SafeMoon app didn’t launch on the introduced day as a result of nobody was conscious of the lengthy approval course of for software program on the Apple App Retailer.
One staffer later reported catching Karony watching a YouTube video titled “How to Be A Better CEO.”
What was SafeMoon… Actually?
The prosecution’s first witness, on Might 6, was William Maurer, an architect from Southern California who invested in SafeMoon beginning in Might of 2021.
Prosecutors used Maurer to stroll the jury by SafeMoon’s whitepaper, technological claims, and guarantees of “safety.”
SafeMoon’s token was launched on the Binance Sensible Chain on March 3, 2021. It was created by Nagy, and due to influencers, wash buying and selling, and a devilishly seductive hook, it grew to become an almost in a single day sensation.
It was a fork of one thing known as Bee Token, with, Nagy wrote in a readme file:
“Some added advantages. First, the dev has minted the tokens — despatched the stability to DxSale for honest launch — after which burned the rest of the tokens. Dev needed to partake in presale.
“Second, utilized the DxSale protocol to foster trust in the community by auto-locking liquidity for 4 years… 100% community owned and driven — no rug is possible. #safemoon join us on our journey safely to the moon!”
Prosecutors had Maurer information the jury by SafeMoon’s core design characteristic: a ten% “tax” on all token gross sales by the BSC-based PancakeSwap DEX.
This was meant to each discourage speculative buying and selling and supply a backstop for the token’s price — half of the tax, or 5% of all gross sales, was despatched into that “auto-locking” liquidity pool.
The opposite half of the tax is perhaps extra attention-grabbing, not financially, however psychologically. 5 % of the Safemoon “exit tax” grew to become “reflections” that redistributed charges to present holders.
So not solely have been SafeMoon sellers punished on the best way out the door, however everybody who caught with the group obtained slightly bit richer.
The tax-and-lock dynamic was the idea for the whitepaper’s reassurances of “100% safety.” The concept was to get all of the price appreciation that appeared to occur to any crypto token, as if by magic, and to remove the dangers of price crashes or “exit scams” by merely punishing folks for promoting.
“Safely to the moon” grew to become an often-repeated slogan — and later, the title of an interesting retrospective podcast by former SafeMoon gross sales employees, which was a supply for a few of what follows.
Whereas intuitively interesting, the tax-and-lock mannequin is basically flawed. Limitations to promoting may appear to assist SafeMoon retain worth… however why precisely wouldn’t it have any worth within the first place?
SafeMoon was regularly accused of being a memecoin as a result of, past the tax, it had no utility or options. Actually, the “tax” arguably harmed SafeMoon’s most fast utility by making it an inefficient medium of alternate.
After SafeMoon, a wierd subsection of the crypto world has come to think about “tokenomics” a synonym for this kind of “tax on selling.” That is dangerously deceptive: “tokenomics” is a way more basic time period for the financial dynamics of a decentralized system through which a token is embedded.
For instance, Bitcoin’s emission of tokens to proof-of-work miners, and the connection between real-world price and mining issue adjustment are a chic financial loop.
SafeMoon’s tax system was only a distracting gadget hooked up to a token that basically did nothing.
At a better stage, SafeMoon’s guarantees of security have been simply as a lot of a purple flag. Monetary devices, particularly those who respect quickly, are inextricable from danger, and makes an attempt to engineer away danger by no means do greater than cover or displace it.
Learn extra: EXCLUSIVE: Ex-SafeMoon CTO admits rug pull, particulars insider exemptions
The core SafeMoon group in all probability didn’t know any higher, although: they’d no skilled finance expertise between them. It’s fairly believable to imagine that the gamers had a naive however real religion of their capability to create a revolutionary monetary instrument out of skinny air.
In his cross-examination of Maurer, Nicholas Smith hammered themes that he would develop all through the trial. He led Maurer to level out that not one of the statements Maurer examine SafeMoon’s “safety” had come instantly from Karony — as a substitute, they have been within the whitepaper.
Smith additionally established that Maurer had made his purchases by BitMart, setting up the argument that liquidity pool funds have been used for the professional function of funding growth to different exchanges.
Weigel then requested Maurer one final query on redirect, bringing the actual core of the case again into focus.
“If you knew the SafeMoon team was draining the liquidity pool, would you have invested?” Weigel requested.
“I would not,” Maurer replied.
Right here we’ve the most important drawback with SafeMoon’s tax-and-lock design. Although Nagy’s preliminary claims have been that liquidity from gross sales was “auto-locking,” the liquidity lock was totally guide and beneath the direct management of the small core group of builders.
Although it claimed to be a “DeFi” undertaking, SafeMoon was on this sense considerably centralized. Liquidity can be locked solely a handful of instances throughout SafeMoon’s existence, with Karony arguing strongly towards a few of the locks.
After April of 2021, prosecutors would present the jury, liquidity was by no means locked once more.
The SafeMoon Military
There was an viewers of roughly 20 folks for the prosecution and protection’s opening statements, largely attorneys engaged on different instances, dropping by for some fast rubbernecking.
Nonetheless, after openings and persevering with all through a lot of the trial, there have been solely six or seven onlookers who weren’t officers of the court docket.
On that first day, I launched myself to one in all them — let’s name him Gabe. Sporting sun shades and a puffer vest with a hoodie, he was clearly not a lawyer. I assumed he was a sufferer, there to look at Karony meet justice.
I used to be each proper and mistaken.
Learn extra: YouTuber Ben Phillips made $12M from SafeMoon crypto pump and dump scheme
Gabe defined that he was certainly a SafeMoon investor — however he was there to help Karony, who he believed had been “framed,” probably by the US authorities. SafeMoon’s tax-and-lock tokenomics, he mentioned, was the undertaking’s key innovation — and, he intimated, a menace to the fiat greenback.
Gabe informed me he made SafeMoon-themed music in help of the undertaking, and I noticed his hoodie bore the SafeMoon brand. The SafeMoon group, he mentioned, was “more active than ever.”
This was removed from the one member of the “SafeMoon Army” nonetheless cheering Karony on. SafeMoon attracted one of the vital intense cults crypto had ever seen, and whereas many former SafeMoon buyers have been immensely supportive of my trial protection, there have been nonetheless loads of die-hards who reflexively declared each phrase “biased” or “FUD.”
They jogged my memory of these apocryphal Japanese troopers trapped on some distant island for many years after World Battle II, nonetheless preventing a long-lost battle.
On that first day, two different onlookers caught round, sitting within the first row of seats, instantly behind the protection desk. One was a bald, bespectacled, long-limbed man in his early sixties, who might be performed within the totally believable SafeMoon Film by Arrested Growth’s Jeffrey Tambor.
Sitting shut and sometimes whispering to him was a red-haired, designer-dressed lady with greater than slightly of Lucille Bluth to her. For day-after-day of the trial, I’d discover them again of their seats, not often betraying any emotion however a sort of mildly amused shock.
I started to suspect who they is perhaps: Karony’s mother and father, Bradford and Jennifer Karony. However it was exhausting to make certain. Bradford is a former Central Intelligence Company staffer, and there are only a few obtainable photographs of the pair.
One of many few is that this video of Bradford discussing careers in intelligence, however the pudgy man in that video seemed nothing just like the lean, wizened determine faithfully displaying up to court docket.
Then, a supply near the household cracked the case for me: Bradford and Jennifer Karony had gone on Ozempic.
Bradford and Jennifer’s presence within the courtroom was placing. Although it barely surfaced within the court docket proceedings, SafeMoon had opened up deep rifts inside the Karony household, significantly between John and his mom.
John had used liquidity pool funds to make a $5 million funding in Emanations Communication Group (ECG), a agency based by Jennifer, simply months after becoming a member of SafeMoon. ECG grew to become a key participant in a later stage of SafeMoon’s story, however issues didn’t go nicely, in the end resulting in Karony submitting swimsuit towards his personal mom.
However maybe that was all water beneath the bridge. Bradford and Jennifer, like Gabe, would attend day-after-day of the trial. When Karony was convicted, I’d glimpse the intelligence-linked mother and father deep in a heartfelt dialog with the anti-government conspiracist.
The White Wizard
John M. Griffin, an professional witness for the prosecution, then walked the jury by the small print of liquidity swimming pools and blockchain. Nicholas Smith took the chance on cross-examination to ask Griffin about the usage of block explorers to establish blockchain transactions, a part of making the case that no person was hiding the unlocked liquidity pool.
He additionally walked Griffin by the comfort advantages of centralized exchanges, constructing the case that “seeding” alternate buying and selling was a professional use of liquidity pool funds.
The prosecution’s star witness was subsequent — Thomas “Papa” Smith, the CTO of SafeMoon throughout its peak, and practically as a lot the face of the undertaking as John Karony.
However when he took the stand, Smith’s trademark beard and lengthy hair had gone from salted black to shockingly, fully gray: it was as if his November 2023 arrest and subsequent dealings with the Feds had actually sucked the life out of him.
He had taken a plea deal to testify towards Karony.
Smith was strikingly relatable on the stand, and appeared genuinely, at instances movingly contrite and regretful about what he had executed — and he laid out precisely what that was for the jury. “We misrepresented our use of a liquidity pool… we lied to the general public.
“We would say we were going to use the money for development, then not do that.”
SafeMoon, Thomas Smith informed the jury, had largely grown from one thing known as Tano, an organization Karony had based to make video games. In response to one other former SafeMoon staffer, one in all its tasks had been known as “Goat Racing Simulator,” a riff on the favored “Goat Simulator” video games.
It appears to have been a shoestring operation — based on Smith, he was paid a mere “$2,000 to $3,000” per thirty days at Tano, and Smith claimed the corporate was funded totally from Karony’s bank card.
It will need to have felt like salvation, then, when Kyle Nagy known as Smith on March 8, 2021, to ask for assist with SafeMoon. The token had already began taking off. Smith was instantly excited, joined up as a developer, and rapidly introduced Karoni alongside to run operations.
Not lengthy after, Nagy gave Thomas Smith $500,000 value of SafeMoon tokens. Enormous “bonuses” have been handed out to Hank Wyatt and Trevor Church on the identical time.
Whereas Nagy claimed these have been SafeMoon tokens he’d purchased with actual cash in the course of the presale, they’d truly been taken from the liquidity pool — the earliest instance of a recurring behavior.
Thomas Smith’s description of what occurred when he all of a sudden had half 1,000,000 {dollars} was simply probably the most poignant testimony of the trial.
“I cried,” Smith mentioned. “I didn’t have to fret about payments, I didn’t have to fret about how I’d eat. I wasn’t capable of save my grandmother’s home [from foreclosure], however I had fully modified in that second.
All the pieces you’re, what makes you, is since you’re working in direction of one thing. And [when you get it], you alter. You possibly can’t assist it.”
He added, “Previously, I had a very strong moral compass. After I had the money, I stopped asking questions, I stopped fighting back. I cared deeply about the amount that I had… I became that monster I was talking about.”
Smith went on to explain simply how keen he grew to become to bend his ethics. This included utilizing obfuscating strategies to cover his gross sales of SafeMoon tokens by PancakeSwap, whereas gleefully celebrating imminent “Castle Money” in DMs with different SafeMooners — most of all, John Karony.
Smith additionally all of a sudden grew to become a fierce warrior towards “FUD,” or “fear, uncertainty, and doubt.” In AMAs or in Discord chats, Smith would “brush off” what turned out to be pretty justified and affordable considerations.
“I paid a lot more attention to FUD after that… it could spiral out of control. If there was an incredible amount of selling, the [value of the] amount that I had could go down.”
Smith testified that a technique SafeMoon calmed down FUD was to “post a new lock” of a tranche of the liquidity pool.
This grew to become a specific level of stress after April 21, 2021, when a game-changing Tweet from an account known as Battle on Rugs claimed, precisely, that “Owner owns more than 50% of the liquidity and refuses to fix it. He could pull LP and sell tokens, creating a rug pull. Likeliness of losing all funds: Absolute.”
Smith described how he and Nagy had tried to persuade Karony to reply by locking about $250 million value of liquidity. By this level, as they argued, SafeMoon was producing loads of charges to pay any ongoing bills.
However, in Discord messages proven by the prosecution, Karony initially refused. “No. I veto. No locking it.”
Notably, although, this enormous lock finally did undergo, over Karony’s preliminary objection. Protection lawyer Nicholas Smith would later cannily recommend that these performative locks truly revealed to customers that the liquidity pool wasn’t as locked as had been marketed.
Thomas Smith additionally described one other portion of the fraud alleged towards Karony, involving the BitMart alternate. SafeMoon’s “tax” system didn’t work when it was offered by centralized exchanges (which one may see as a fairly elementary failing), however Karony had satisfied BitMart to copy its mechanics.
Nonetheless, Smith testified that as a substitute of tax funds going again into the liquidity pool, they went instantly right into a “market-making” account managed by Karony.
It was at this stage of the trial that I had my first direct interplay with Karony. Throughout a break, I used to be within the courtroom speaking to a fellow reporter. Karony walked up to us, smiling, hand prolonged. “Thanks for covering this,” he informed us.
Possibly it simply confirmed that Karony was, as some former staff would keep, a genuinely good man. However it was undeniably weird — in years of court docket expertise between us two reporters, nothing prefer it had ever occurred.
Over the next 10 days of the trial, different prosecution proof would set up the conspiracy and its targets much more definitively.
In a really early AMA discuss, Karony was seen mendacity to the SafeMoon group that he and the group have been being paid “a little bit,” and that he solely held about $30 value of SafeMoon himself — regardless of having been gifted 5 trillion SFM tokens, value thousands and thousands of {dollars}.
Prosecutors introduced one other video that they mentioned Karony had made from himself, on the telephone or a video chat with somebody who feels like Thomas Smith. They’re discussing cash and payroll when Karony refers to “bonuses that don’t exist.”
Extra fraudulent statements got here after the Battle on Rugs tweet in April. In a sequence of all-caps X posts, Karony informed the group that the liquidity pool funds is perhaps used for “EMERGENCIES” however that “WE WILL PUBLICLY GO TO THE COMMUNITY” forward of time if that was needed.
Actually, LP funds would proceed being pulled out for any variety of non-emergency purposes, and the group was by no means notified forward of any of it.
“There is no coming back from this lie,” as Rehnquist would declare in her closing.
Monetary particulars additionally continued to emerge. Ultimately, “Papa” Smith acquired greater than $2 million value of property for his function. One other prime staffer named Hank Wyatt obtained $800,000 for lower than a 12 months’s work.
Withdrawals from the liquidity pool continued nicely after SafeMoon’s temporary interval within the solar had handed: a forensic accountant testified that between September and mid-December of 2021, $43 million was pulled out.
In one other set of Discord messages, Nagy asks Karony if they need to “be honest with the team” about having tapped the liquidity pool. Karony replies that they “need to talk about how to message that properly.”
In the end, that meant by no means disclosing it in any respect. As a substitute, Karony steered taking out extra money.
As Dana Rehnquist would declare in her closing assertion for the prosecution: “That’s the conspiracy.”
The protection
Although he didn’t come out on prime, Nicholas Smith did some spectacular lawyering all through the trial. One significantly robust instance got here in his cross-examination of his namesake “Papa” Smith.
Thomas Smith had described receiving a $500,000 present, however Nicholas Smith made certain he clarified for the jury that this present was from Nagy and had nothing on to do with Karony.
He obtained Thomas Smith to acknowledge that there was substantial disagreement, each in DeFi generally and inside SafeMoon, about whether or not it was acceptable to faucet a liquidity pool for bills (if this was ever truly a widespread debate in DeFi, I missed it on the time, however the reply is now fairly clearly “no”).
Extra pointedly, Nicholas Smith highlighted a March 19, 2021, video AMA through which Thomas Smith talked about {that a} portion of the liquidity pool was not locked, explaining that it is because locking the whole pool would make it more durable to repair issues.
“If you’re trying to lead people to believe that the entire liquidity pool was locked,” Nicholas Smith requested, “This isn’t very effective, is it?”
On the one hand, this was a really efficient line of questioning. However Nicholas Smith’s energetic type had a draw back: the protection lawyer appeared, now and at different factors, smarmy and superior.
Over the course of the trial, he would frequently conflict with Decide Komitee whereas arguing process — kind of within the job description for protection attorneys, however not totally preferrred.
Smith additionally didn’t reach mounting a really strong protection when it got here time to name his personal witnesses. Jake Hammock, former SafeMoon VP of product, testified to the fact of later deliberate SafeMoon merchandise, comparable to a decentralized alternate and an encryption software known as Orbital Defend.
These merchandise have been by no means launched regardless of massive guarantees from the SafeMoon group, however they weren’t a spotlight of the fraud fees.
Hammock additionally testified that he discovered Karony to have a law-abiding character. However on cross-examination, this gave the prosecution a gap to ask Hammock whether or not he knew that in 2021, regardless of making thousands and thousands of {dollars}, Karony “did not file or pay taxes,” or that Karony had “bribed Gambian officials.”
That final allegation was first put forth in proceedings between Karony and his mom.
Smith additionally questioned a seemingly happy SafeMoon investor named Nicholas Ranalli. A gray-haired auto plant employee from Canada, Ranalli had acted as a moderator on SafeMoon’s Fb web page, and testified that Karony had certainly disclosed that the liquidity pool was getting used — and that Ranalli didn’t have any drawback with that.
Ranalli admitted to prosecutors, although, that he was nonetheless holding all of his SafeMoon, and “hoping the price will go up.”
Karony’s protection had a forensic professional of its personal, Rutgers economics professor Bruce Mizrach. Mizrach primarily charted SafeMoon’s price towards the announcement of latest liquidity “lock” bulletins, which confirmed these “locks” taking place after price declines, and being adopted by price rises.
I used to be unclear of the aim right here — Mizrach’s chart appeared primarily to help Thomas Smith’s earlier declare that making quite a lot of noise about liquidity locks was a great way to distract the SafeMoon Military from unhealthy information.
In his closing assertion, Nicholas Smith reiterated the pillars of his protection: That Karony didn’t write the preliminary misleading SafeMoon whitepaper or web site; that he barely understood crypto; that SafeMoon leaders had disclosed that the liquidity pool was not “locked” (albeit not directly); that the group had disagreed about whether or not to make use of the liquidity pool.
“Conspiracy requires agreement,” Smith argued.
Smith additionally performed up SafeMoon’s sources of money apart from the liquidity pool, together with merchandise gross sales, and equated claims that SafeMoon was “safe” to a salesman’s puffed-up pitch: one thing no affordable particular person would take actually.
It was all strong lawyering — but it surely didn’t make a distinction to the decision.
The jury deliberated for roughly three hours. John Karony was responsible, responsible, responsible.
Conviction
After the jury returned their verdict, issues weren’t fairly over.
The prosecution and protection now made arguments a few forfeiture judgment towards $1.8 million in proceeds from the sale of his Utah mansion, in addition to $107,000 that forensics had traced from the SafeMoon liquidity pool to the down cost on Brandon and Jennifer Karony’s residence.
When the jury retired to deliberate on the forfeiture, I stepped out for some water. On my approach again, I crossed paths with Karony and Nicholas Smith, seemingly headed to the toilet.
I walked previous the now-convicted man with out acknowledging the pair. However then, from behind me, got here Karony’s chummy shout.
“David, they’re not back yet!” He appeared gentle, blithe, nice — in no way like somebody who had simply been convicted of against the law that may ship them to jail for 4 many years.
I used to be raised proper — to look folks within the eye, provide a agency handshake, to say please and thanks. However I used to be so surprised by the strangeness of it (and admittedly, so anxious about showing pleasant in direction of Karony) that I didn’t reply in any respect.
Completely icing somebody isn’t actually my approach. It was impolite.
However I can’t say I really feel too unhealthy.
Acquired a tip? Ship us an e mail securely by way of Protos Leaks. For extra knowledgeable information, comply with us on X, Bluesky, and Google Information, or subscribe to our YouTube channel.