If the Taylor Wimpey (LSE: TW) share price was a home, I wouldn’t purchase it. It’s received a extreme case of subsidence proper now, having fallen 45% over the previous 5 years, with a 20% slide within the final yr alone.

Loads of traders have parted with their cash although, me included. They thought the FTSE 100 housebuilder was a cut price, however each time the inventory appeared to stabilise, it was hit by one other earth tremor. So is it time to maneuver on?

Writing for The Motley Idiot, I’ve discovered to not abandon a share simply because it’s out of favour with the broader market. In truth, that’s usually a set off for me to purchase. Troubled corporations usually bounce again stronger, however it may take time. That’s definitely the case right here.

Can this FTSE 100 straggler battle again?

Taylor Wimpey’s share price struggles displays a difficult surroundings for UK housebuilders. 

Rising mortgage charges have hit affordability, whereas broader financial uncertainty cools demand. The associated fee-of-living disaster has pushed up the price of supplies, and post-pandemic provide chain challenges linger. 

On 16 January, Taylor Wimpey confirmed the influence. UK completions fell to 9,972 final yr, down from 10,356 in 2023. The general common promoting price slipped to £319,000, from £324,000.

On paper, Taylor Wimpey shares appear like a cut price. With a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio beneath 12, the inventory is cheaper than the typical FTSE 100 P/E of round 15 instances. Its trailing dividend yield of 8.1% is eye-catching, providing a considerably larger revenue than money, bonds and most FTSE 100 shares.

Dividend payouts hinge on profitability, and Taylor Wimpey dangers margin compression as gross sales shrink and prices rise. Upcoming nationwide insurance coverage hikes for employers received’t assist, nor will the elevated minimal wage. 

The group does boast a sturdy stability sheet and ended 2024 with a £2bn order e book, however sustaining such a beneficiant yield may turn into difficult if market situations deteriorate additional. The forecast yield of 8.6% is roofed simply as soon as by earnings, worryingly. Taylor Wimpey has monitor report of dividend will increase, however nothing is assured.

Can the dividend compensate for misplaced progress?

So can the share price get well? The 16 analysts providing one-year share price forecasts have produced a median goal of simply over 148p. If appropriate, that’s a rise of round 25% from immediately. Mixed with that yield, it could give traders a complete return of 33% if true. Appears optimistic to me, however we’ll see.

The UK does face a power below provide of housing. This could assist demand whereas that fats order e book brings visibility.

What Taylor Wimpey shares really want is a string of rate of interest cuts. That may shrink mortgage charges, revive the economic system and ease price pressures too. It could additionally make that dividend look even higher, relative to yields on money and bonds.

In my opinion, this isn’t sport over for Taylor Wimpey. However traders tempted by that yield should realise this can be a unstable sector on the entrance line of each financial challenge. The share price is definitely decrease than it was 10 years in the past. Even the good dividend can not completely compensate for that. Regardless of my issues, I’ll play on. I nonetheless assume it’s a winner over time.